In early 2020, when COVID-19 was spreading globally, 59% of countries surveyed by a World Health Organization rapid assessment reported that access to outpatient non-communicable (NCD) services was restricted to a certain degree . Public health systems faced the dual challenge of containing the outbreak while protecting health care workers (HCW) and maintaining routine services for hypertension, diabetes, and other chronic NCDs . In Thailand, patients living with chronic diseases, especially elderly individuals and those with comorbidities, were unable or reluctant to visit health facilities for routine care. There were also challenges in maintaining NCD case management and screening programs for early detection of NCDs . Outpatient visits decreased at a national level and in Bangkok . This article aims to document innovative practices adopted by Pakkred Hospital of the Ministry of Public Health in Thailand to overcome challenges generated by COVID-19 and to assess whether they contributed to maintaining chronic care for patients with hypertension and diabetes.
Pakkred, a semi-urban district in the Nonthaburi Province of Thailand, had a population of 249,415 in 2019 . The percentage of the population that is over 60 years old is 18.2%, and the majority have pre-existing chronic NCDs that require ongoing management. The numbers of patients on treatment for hypertension or diabetes in Pakkred Hospital are 5,881 and 3,015, respectively.
Since 2002, Thailand has provided universal health coverage through three public health insurance schemes. The health system in Pakkred consists of one public district hospital, two private hospitals, one university hospital, and eight health-promoting hospitals (HPHs). HPHs, each staffed by 3–5 nurses, are the first point of medical contact for the population and provide preventive and basic medical services, including hypertension and diabetes treatment. A doctor, nurse, pharmacist, and counselor from the district hospital visit weekly and oversee monthly NCD clinics at the HPHs. Pakkred is supported by approximately 240 community health volunteers (CHVs) who provide health promotion, disease prevention, and basic disease management services including chronic NCD care.
During Thailand’s COVID-19 pandemic, the health leadership of Pakkred Hospital prioritized maintaining essential services for patients with chronic diseases. As of March 16, 2020, several changes to primary health care were instituted in Pakkred District.
After review of patient records by a nurse and doctor, patients with established diabetes or hypertension control were provided with repeat prescriptions and were given the option of having their medication delivered in the following ways:
For patients with uncontrolled blood pressure (BP) or limited mobility, CHVs equipped with personal protective equipment measured BP at patients’ homes and transferred results to physicians, who adjusted prescriptions as needed.
Hospitals and HPHs implemented new measures to reduce COVID-19 exposure risk for patients with uncontrolled NCDs that still needed to visit facilities. Ventilation was improved, seating arrangements ensured physical distancing, additional outdoor patient waiting areas were implemented, number of patients indoors was restricted, and plastic screens were added as barriers at all points of contact with HCWs.
Additionally, a fast-track system was implemented for patients presenting to the hospital only for chronic NCD care. Patients received screening, measurement, consultation, and medications all in one place. For well-controlled patients, follow-up appointments were spaced 1–2 months longer during the peak COVID-19 period and staggered to reduce crowding at facilities.
To minimize unnecessary travel, LINE software text-messaging accounts were created for NCD clinics to enable online real-time or asynchronous consultations between hospital staff and patients, prescription refills, or medication pick-up or delivery. The LINE application also enabled 24/7 communication between doctors, nurses, CHVs, and home health care teams. A secure Facebook page was created for patient inquiries and to facilitate patient follow-up.
The number of patients with hypertension on treatment who visited outpatient departments (OPDs) at the hospital declined from March to May 2020, followed by a period of slow return to the hospital for care (Figure 1). By September 2020, the number of hypertension patients on treatment visiting hospital OPDs reached just over 3000, a number similar to one year prior, before the epidemic (September 2019). The hypertension control rate among all patients registered for treatment was maintained through the COVID-19 epidemic. Only 1% of patients could not be contacted for treatment or medicine refill. By September 2020, the hypertension control rate was 67% (3944/5,881), compared to 64% (3838/6055) in September 2019. The diabetes control rate was 24% (742/3079) in September 2019 and increased to 31% (941/3015) in September 2020.
Achievements during March–June 2020:
The response in Pakkred, Thailand, succeeded in delivering essential medical services to NCD patients during the Covid-19 epidemic. Several innovative practices initiated during the acute phase of the epidemic should continue in the long-term to improve patient-centered care for controlled NCD patients, including decentralized care, telemedicine, home BP monitoring, and community delivery of medicines. A pre-existing strong primary health care infrastructure, a network of CHVs, and a communications infrastructure provided the foundation for an innovative program to maintain essential NCD services.
Control rates are from the Health Data Center of the Ministry of Public Health, Thailand . The outpatient department visit data are from the electronic health service record of Pakkred Hospital. This data is available upon reasonable request.
No ethics approval was sought for this study because it describes usual, standard clinical care and summary data that were abstracted from routine electronic health records data gathered in public sector health care facilities.
Danielle Cazabon and Andrew E. Moran receive salary support from Resolve to Save Lives, an initiative of Vital Strategies. Resolve to Save Lives is jointly supported by grants from Bloomberg Philanthropies, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation, and Gates Philanthropy Partners, which is funded with support from the Chan Zuckerberg Foundation.
The authors have no competing interests to declare.
All authors made substantial contributions to the conception or design of the work, the drafting or critical revision of the work, and approved the final product. All authors agreed to be on the author list and approved the final author list.
World Health Organization. The impact of the COVID-19 pandemic on noncommunicable disease resources and services: Results of a rapid assessment. Geneva 2020.
World Health Organization MoPH. Joint intra-action review of the public health response to COVID-19 in Thailand. 2020. 20–24 July, 2020.
Tangcharoensathien V, Bassett MT, Meng Q, Mills A. Are overwhelmed health systems an inevitable consequence of Covid-19? Experiences from China, Thailand, and New York State. BMJ. 2021; 372.
Nonthaburi Provincial Statistical Office. Nonthaburi Provincial Statistical Report: 2020. Bangkok: National Statistics Office; 2020.
Ministry of Public Health Thailand. Thailand Ministry of Public Health’s Health Data Center 2021 [Available from: https://hdcservice.moph.go.th/hdc/main/index.php].